Black Walnut Ice Cream

Reihonna--I had no idea what this would be like. I thought it might be a beige nutty ice cream with a slightly buttery taste. Or, it could be nutty and bitter. The actual ice cream was white with big hunks of walnuts in it. The ice cream was fine, I think it tasted slightly nutty but mostly just vanilla-like. The nuts, however, were awful. They were stale and bitter and chewy. They were so bad that I started spitting them out about half way through the ice cream and I pushed a bunch of the ice cream off of my cone into the First Merit Bank lawn so that I didn't have to eat it. Ewww. This is officially the first ice cream in this experiment that I didn't finish.

Would you order it again: No, no, no.
Would you recommend it to someone else? No, there has to be better walnut ice cream. Anyone that likes walnuts would be disapointed.
Scale of 1 to 10: 1

Ian: This ice cream is a good concept, a subtle ice cream flavor with a really nice texture contrast: the walnuts. This held true for the first bite, but then Reihonna and I began to notice pretty quickly that the nuts were stale, so that kind of ruining it. Also there was a mysterious sewage smell wafting about (not ice cream related), so we walked over to the bank. I'd say don't buy this until you know for a fact it's fresh batch.

Would you order it again? No
Would you recommend it to someone else? No, quality was lacking this time.
Scale of 1 to 10: 2